had you going through?是不是和had you BEEN going through 一样?

had you going through?是不是和had you BEEN going through 一样?
had you going through?是不是和had you BEEN going through 一样?

had you going through?是不是和had you BEEN going through 一样?
不一样.
had you going through这句话是不成立的.
have done sth.是固定用法,而have been doing sth.是它的进行时.

前一句错
后一句是过去完成进行时

第一个是你做完了吗？现在正在进行
第二个是你曾经做完过吗？是过去完成的一个动作

不一样.