On the other hand, he did not accept as well founded the charge ...句子结构分析On the other hand, he did not accept as well founded the charge made by some of his critics that while he was a good observer, he had no power of reasoning.这是解

来源:学生作业帮助网 编辑:作业帮 时间:2024/04/30 14:25:05

On the other hand, he did not accept as well founded the charge ...句子结构分析On the other hand, he did not accept as well founded the charge made by some of his critics that while he was a good observer, he had no power of reasoning.这是解
On the other hand, he did not accept as well founded the charge ...句子结构分析
On the other hand, he did not accept as well founded the charge made by some of his critics that while he was a good observer, he had no power of reasoning.
这是解析:本句考查点是同位语从句,让步状语从句.主干是he did not accept… the charge made by… that….其中as well founded作为一个插入成分,对charge进行修饰.made引导的过去分词短语作定语修饰charge.That引导的从句是charge的同位语,包括一个while引导的让步状语从句.
我没搞懂的是as well founded 是怎样修饰charge的呢? 在句中是什么意思呢? 谢谢了!
谢谢下面的回答。
但我问题的重点在于 as well founded在句中是什么意思,谢谢了!

On the other hand, he did not accept as well founded the charge ...句子结构分析On the other hand, he did not accept as well founded the charge made by some of his critics that while he was a good observer, he had no power of reasoning.这是解
he did not accept as well founded the charge made by some of his critics
as well founded
有2种理解,1. as 理解为 连词=though,即连接2个分句. well 副词修饰 founded. founded 为过去时.因为2个分句主语一致所以省略的主语 he
2. as well 理解为词组= also, 副词,因为缺少连词,所以,founded 不能理解为谓语动词,只能理解为过去分词做定语修饰名词成分(之后的 the charge).即解析中所说.
我个人认为不宜理解为 2.,理解为1.更适当,因为理解为连词有让步的意思,即 as=though, 同时,即使.
这样,如果分成2句话的话就是:
he did not accept the charge made by some of his critics, as he well founded the charge made by some of his critics
他不接受一些对他提出批评的批评家的指控,(即使)同时他使得这些指控成立了.
也就是说 did not accept ,和 well founded 共用主语 he,并且共用宾语 the charge.
而理解为2. founded理解为过去分词做定语修饰名词成分(之后的 the charge)则只是说这个指控是成立的(被动语态),而没有他使得这个指控成立了的意思,似乎与讽刺的语境不符.因为之后提到了批评他没有推理能力(he had no power of reasoning),隐含着指控(the charge)完全成立(well founded)的原因.
that while he was a good observer, he had no power of reasoning.同位语从句=the charge 的内容,即 (虽然)他是个好的观察者,但却没有推理能力.不多做解释了.

as well founded确实是一个插入成分。
咱们可以把as well founded去掉来看句子,是这样的:he did not accept the charge made……